A prebiotic soda that’s also a dirty soda? Or a dirty soda that’s also a prebiotic soda?
A quick review of Slice Dirty Soda, with a bonus review of Good & Gather Prebiotic Soda.
A quick review of Slice Dirty Soda, with a bonus review of Good & Gather Prebiotic Soda.
The product: Slice Dirty Soda
The cost: A 12 oz. can is $2.59 at Target

Welcome to Snackology!
This publication is a free newsletter, but it’s fueled by readers like you. Support independent news, reviews and more for just $5 a month.
Upgrade to PaidIncludes full access to Popculturology and The Cold Open.

Two major soda trends collide with Slice Dirty Soda. I’ve gotten fully into prebiotic sodas the past few months, stocking our fridge with Poppi, Olipop and even Pepsi Prebiotic Soda. And I’ve had my fair share of dirty sodas from Taco Bell.
“Dirty soda has quickly become one of the most talked-about beverage trends, but until now, consumers had to make it themselves or settle for versions that didn't quite deliver the full experience,” Slice parent company Suja Life said in its announcement. “Rather than artificial cream flavors, we’ve added MCT oil to create the smooth, indulgent mouthfeel that defines a true dirty soda, capturing the creamy indulgence people love while staying true to our mission of offering a better-for-you soda.”
OK, I’m not quite about the science here, but I think Slice is trying to say that they’ve delivered a truer canned dirty soda than like what we’ve gotten from Dirty Dew.
Both flavors of Slice Dirty Soda were enjoyable. Dirty Orange predictably comes close to a creamsicle flavor, while Dirty Strawberry is a take on strawberries and cream that comes across a touch too sweet. I’d definitely drink the Dirty Orange flavor again.

The product: Good & Gather Prebiotic Soda
The cost: A 12 oz. can is $2.19 at Target
In addition to being the exclusive home of Slice prebiotic soda, Target is also rolling out its own in-house lineup of prebiotic soda through the Good & Gather label. For its launch, Good & Gather Prebiotic Soda will be available in Grape, Cherry Citrus and Strawberry Vanilla.
I’m a big fan of the grape Olipop flavor, and I found Good & Gather’s version to not have the same oomph as it. (Which, depending how grape-y you want your grape soda to be, can be a good or bad thing.) But Cherry Citrus and Strawberry Vanilla? Oh boy, those two are home runs.
Slice Dirty Soda and Good & Gather Prebiotic Soda were provided to Snackology for this independent review.

Snackology is a publication of The Omnicosm.
Issue No. 284
Snackology is written and produced by Bill Kuchman.
Copyediting by Tim Kuchman.
Love what Snackology is doing? You can help keep the newsletter going by becoming a paid supporter.
If this edition of Snackology brought you joy, consider sending a tip.
Get the full The Omnicosm experience. Add Popculturology and The Cold Open to your subscription via your account settings.
Join the hundreds of subscribers who already get the free Snackology, Popculturology and The Cold Open newsletters.