Oreo Santas shoot to the top of the nice list
A quick review of the Christmas version of the fantastic Oreo Ghosts.
It’s been a decade since the Disney classic hit theaters, and we’ve already gotten a retrofitted animated sequel and an ill-fated live-action remake. But the future of ‘Moana’ is bright.
“Dad, is there a Moana 3?”
That’s what my daughter asked me a few weeks ago. She’s almost 5, and over the past year, she decided that Moana was her favorite Disney princess. I’ve lost track of how many times she’s watched both animated movies. (Moana 2 is her favorite.) She was Moana for Halloween.
I love watching my daughter fall in love with something. Especially when it’s something that I love too.
Moana is also my favorite Disney princess.
I swear that I didn’t force Moana on my daughter. Did I try? Absolutely. But the movies clicked on their own for her. There’s no way I would’ve ever instilled that Moana 2 — the Disney+ series that Bob Iger had retrofitted into a movie — is the superior Moana movie.
So back to the question of whether there’s a Moana 3. The simple answer is no. But the more hopeful answer is not yet.
This weekend is the tenth anniversary of Moana hitting theaters.
The original animated film premiered on Nov. 23, 2016. This might blow your mind, but I didn’t see Moana in theaters. There was never a conscientious decision to not see Moana when it opened. My wife and I got married in October 2016, and then went to Maui (the island!) for our honeymoon, so you’d think we were right in the target audience for this movie.
The memory of being emotionally devastated by Arrival just days after the 2016 presidential election is forever etched in my brain, but we didn’t return to the Regal Cinema that once stood across the street from our apartment complex a few weeks later for Moana.
Even before we had a daughter to fall in love with Moana, I made up for our mistake of skipping the animated film in theaters by watching it countless times at home. Gramma Tala returning to guide Moana toward the end of the film always breaks me.
I can effortlessly argue that Moana is Disney’s biggest accomplishment of its second renaissance. (Sorry, Frozen.) It made Auliʻi Cravalho a star. It’s Dwayne Johnson’s best role. And its songs are the epitome of Lin-Manuel Miranda’s work.
I’m not sure that Disney believed in Moana like I do, though.
While the studio was releasing animated theatrical sequels to Frozen and Wreck-It Ralph, Disney decided that Moana needed to be an animated series on Disney+. And with the animated version of the franchise relegated to streaming, Disney announced that Johnson was leading a live-action remake of Moana.
Forget that when Johnson triumphantly declared that he would play Maui in the remake, it hadn’t even been seven years since the original Moana premiered. If there was ever proof that Disney’s live-action remake machine existed solely to print money, this project made it very clear.
But then Iger threw a wrench into that machine.
Disney knew enough to not cross the streams when it came to these live-action remakes. The studio only greenlit live-action remakes for animated franchises that were no longer active. There’ll never be a live-action Frozen as long as the animated Frozen III and Frozen IV are in the works.
Despite Johnson willing a live-action Moana remake to life, Disney announced that Moana 2 was coming to theaters over Thanksgiving 2024. The studio was reportedly so pleased with how the Moana Disney+ series that everyone had forgotten about was progressing that Iger decided it should be cobbled together into a theatrical release.
Never mind that Miranda didn’t write any of the songs for what would become Moana 2 or that Cravalho and Johnson didn’t even seem to be on board when the film was first announced, an animated Moana sequel was heading to theaters.
Moana 2 grossed an insane $225.4 million over the five-day Thanksgiving weekend. (The original Moana’s entire domestic haul was $248.8 million.) People wanted an animated Moana sequel, and it didn’t matter if it wasn’t great.
At this point, Disney should’ve cancelled the live-action Moana remake. Nothing good was going to come out of having active animated and live-action paths for the franchise. Disney couldn’t announce an animated Moana 3 as long as the live-action remake was hanging out on the calendar.
Disney unfortunately and foolishly sent the live-action Moana remake to theaters this past summer. It flopped. It flopped harder than almost any other live-action remake that Disney has released.
People didn’t want this movie. People understood that it was a cash grab. People saw that it was creatively bankrupt.
The silver lining to the live-action Moana remake’s failure, though, is that Disney has finally gotten the project out of its system. It doesn’t have to pretend that Johnson in a Spirit Halloween wig is the future of Moana.
So when my daughter asked me “Dad, is there a Moana 3?” a few weeks ago, I told her that there isn’t one yet. But I think we’ll find out that it’s in the works soon. A sequel has to be in the works.
We don’t talk enough about how wild the ending of Moana 2 was. Moana dies. She dies! And then she’s brought back as a demigod.
An announcement of new sequel didn’t come at D23 this past summer. But I bet you that by this time next year, we’ll have confirmation that Moana 3 is on the calendar. It’ll be animated. It’ll have Miranda writing songs. And it’ll be the proper continuation of the series that fans have wanted since Moana premiered a decade ago.
Popculturology is a publication of The Omnicosm.
Issue No. 516
Popculturology is written and produced by Bill Kuchman.
Copyediting by Tim Kuchman.
Get the full The Omnicosm experience. Add Snackology and The Cold Open to your subscription via your account settings.
Love reading Snackology, Popculturology and The Cold Open? Get the entire family of newsletters from The Omnicosm in your inbox.